EDIT: Whoah nelly! I just hit Hot Topic and the figure is not as nice as I hoped. The paint job is a bit sloppy, but more importantly they have kind of "jowels" I guess? Anyway, the faces are a bit weird and it's just enough off-standard that I figure I won't be buying them after all. They're still really nice though but you may want to check them in the store first like I did.
ORIGINAL POST BELOW THE LINE
Guys, Hasbro has FINALLY done it (or at least this is the best they've done so far)!
Hot Topic is selling the most accurate figures I've seen and they're only $15 each. I'm heading over to my store later to see if they're in stock, but there can be ordered online too.
Right now they only have RD and Derpy, but DERPY!!!
I hope they sell a million of these and start taking us bronies more seriously (Could a show-accurate plush be too much to ask for?)